We have played the game 3 times so far (twice as 2-player and once as 6-player) and have enjoyed it! The theme and historical setting are very well integrated into the game and make it particularly enjoyable as a Christian (but the game would still be great even if you are not religious). The elder staff and messenger die are a good way to ensure everyone can participate with minimal "quarterbacking", and the difficulty level felt good for a co-op game on regular difficulty (not too easy but doesn't require you to play perfectly to win). I anticipate there will be good replayability with the 2 difficulty levels, 6 characters, 5 missions, and also the 1-vs-all mode. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because the rulebook could have been slightly more clear. The game is fairly easy to learn, but I came across a few questions that either took a while for me to find the answer in the rulebook, and one I had to search online forums to find the answer.