For our group, Agricola is probably THE desert island game. It’s always captivating with enough similarity between games that you don’t feel like you are re-learning the game on each playthrough, but enough variability that no two games feel the same.
Brew Crafters has a very similar feel to Agricola, though not quite as much variability. If you love Agricola, but you want to change things up a bit, Brew Crafters is an excellent way to go.